Tackling information silo sources
There are many reasons information silos exist. Here, we'll highlight a few
of them. We will address only those issues where information silos
pop up in the presence of an integrated information system.
Where an integrated information system does
not exist, this is the fault of senior management and you can change
it only at that level. If accounting has one information system and
sales another, this is a strategic issue for senior management to
solve.
People create their own information silos primarily
for these reasons:
-
The integrated information system provides data,
not reports. This is the major reason. This article will help
you correct that problem:
http://www.crystalkeen.com/articles/crystaladmins/reportvsdata.htm
-
Users misunderstand what information they actually
need. So, they collect data on their own and make decisions based on
that. When the manager of Dept X meets with the manager of Dept Y,
each is working from a different page and you have an adversarial
contest instead of two departments of the same company working
together.
-
Old customs die hard. Very few people continually
learn and evolve in their jobs. This is why you have heard the
expression "six months of experience 40 times" in reference to a
claim of "20 years of experience." People tend to go on autopilot,
repeating what they learned. On the one hand, this prevents
reinventing the wheel. On the other hand, it keeps people from
moving forward. People who did their jobs a certain way prior to the
introduction of a company-wide information system are likely to keep
doing their jobs the same way. To counter this, you have to show how
the new way makes their jobs easier.
-
Insecurity. Someone who has been sequestering
information over the past 20 years sees that practice as a source of
power within the organization and is loathe to give it up. To
counter this, you need to ensure these people have control. Control
of what? That's a question you can answer only after finding out
where their control hot buttons are. Typically, people aren't
concerned so much with controlling the data as they are with having
control--or at least significant input--on what gets done with the
data. One way to address this is to establish advisory panels or
review committees. This way, people don't feel left out of the loop
and that's usually enough to settle the control issue.
-
Stupidity. This is a very real problem, today.
People don't read, don't perform critical analysis, and don't think
about the purpose they are serving in the organization. So, they do
things that are utterly stupid. For example, Jim gives his password
to a client. Now you have a security breach. Angela, the VP, finds
out and responds to the stupidity by sealing off an entire category
of information into a silo.
One thing you can do in response to the stupidity problem is to
think about what stupid things people might do and try to make
systems more "idiot-proof." You can also present information in a
way that challenges people to think--to do some critical
analysis and consider the reason their jobs exist in the first
place. In the example with Jim, would the outcome have been
different if department managers had meetings with their employees
and an outside security expert to discuss security issues?
You can't anticipate everything that people might do. But, you can
address the important issues and ask people to think about those
things themselves.
There is far more to this topic than we've presented
here. We hope you will make a point of finding information silos and
integrating them back into your system. Some book recommendations to
help you with that are below.
Books to Help You Eliminate Information Silos
-
A Practical Guide to Information Systems
Process Improvement by Anita Cassidy and Keith
Guggenberger (Hardcover
- Sep 26, 2000)
-
BIG BIM little bim - The practical approach to
Building Information Modeling - Integrated practice done the right
way! by Finith Jernigan
(Paperback
- Nov 11, 2007)
-
CIO Best Practices: Enabling Strategic Value
with Information Technology (Wiley and SAS Business Series)
by Joe Stenzel, Gary Cokins, Bill Flemming, and Anthony Hill
(Hardcover -
Feb 2, 2007)
-
Decision Support for Global Enterprises
(Annals of Information Systems) by Uday Kulkarni, Daniel
J. Power, and Ramesh Sharda (Paperback
- Dec 11, 2006)
-
Enterprise Architecture As Strategy: Creating
a Foundation for Business Execution by Jeanne W. Ross,
Peter Weill, and David Robertson (Hardcover
- Aug 8, 2006)
-
Managing Information Assurance in Financial
Services by H. R. Rao, Manish Gupta, and Shambhu J.
Upadhyaya (Hardcover
- May 30, 2007)
-
Managing Information & Systems by
Adrienne Curry, Ivan Hollingworth, and Peter Flett
(Paperback -
Jan 13, 2006)
-
Strategies and Technologies for Healthcare
Information: Theory Into Practice by L.D. Grandia, Marion
J. Ball, Judith V. Douglas, and David E. Garets
(Hardcover -
Jun 3, 1999)
-
The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Management,
Management Information Systems (Blackwell Encyclopaedia of
Management) by Steve Nickles and Gordon B. Davis
(Hardcover -
Jul 11, 2006)
-
The Performance Manager: Proven Strategies for
Turning Information into Higher Business Performance by
Roland Mosimann; Patrick Mosimann; and Meg Dussault and John
Blackmore (Paperback
- Jan 24, 2007)
This article is copyrighted by Crystalkeen, Mindconnection, and Chelsea Technologies Ltd.
It may be freely copied and distributed as long as the
original copyright is displayed and no modifications are made to this
material. Extracts are permitted. The names Crystal Reports and Seagate
Info are trademarks owned by Business Objects. |